Portable vs standby generator

Choose a portable generator if you want backup for essentials at the lowest cost and don't mind wheeling it out, fueling it and connecting it during each outage. Choose a standby generator if you want the house powered automatically within seconds, including central air, with nobody home and no fuel to store.

Updated

What each one is

A portable generator sits on wheels or a frame, runs on gasoline, propane or both, and is stored in a shed or garage. When the power goes out you roll it outside, start it, and either plug appliances into it with extension cords or feed the panel through a transfer switch or interlock kit.

A standby generator is installed permanently on a pad outside the house, plumbed to natural gas or a propane tank, and wired through an automatic transfer switch. It exercises itself on a schedule, starts when utility power fails and shuts down when power returns.

Side by side

Portable Standby
Starts You, by hand or button Automatically
Fuel Gasoline, propane, or both Natural gas or propane, piped in
Fuel storage Cans or cylinders you keep and rotate None for natural gas; a tank for propane
Runtime Until the tank or cylinder runs out As long as the gas supply lasts
Power Essentials to much of a house Essentials to the whole house
Connection Cords, or interlock or manual transfer switch Automatic transfer switch
Installation Inlet and interlock or switch by an electrician Electrician, gas fitter, permits, a pad
Placement during use Outside only, at least 20 ft from the house Fixed, per the maker's installation clearances
Cost Lower Much higher, installed
Noise Varies widely Enclosed; noise varies by model

The live tables on the portable generators and standby generators pages list 143 portable and 20 standby models with their source documents.

Cost

A portable generator plus an interlock kit or manual transfer switch, installed by an electrician, costs a fraction of a standby system. Standby cost includes the unit, the automatic transfer switch, the concrete or composite pad, the electrical work, the gas line, permits and sometimes a gas meter upgrade from the utility.

This site lists manufacturer list prices on each model page with the date checked. Installation varies so much by house and region that the only useful figure is a written quote from a local licensed installer.

Power

Portable generators cover essentials easily, and larger open-frame units with 240 V outlets can run a well pump or some central air through a panel. You choose which breakers to turn on and keep the load under the rating.

Standby generators are built to carry more, and with load management they can back up every circuit in the house. For scale, the Generac Guardian 22 kW is rated at 19,500 W on natural gas. A large portable unit is rated at a fraction of that. The standby sizing guide covers how they're sized.

Home standby generators Checked on
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect 13 kW 11.5 13 119 62 ft3/h 315 7 years parts, labor and travel for emergency stationary use (generator, USA and Canada); enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through $4,460
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect 18 kW 18 18 not published not published 465 7-year comprehensive limited warranty $5,746
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect 22 kW 22 22 194 87 ft3/h 465 7 years parts, labor and travel (generator, domestic and Canada); 7 years or 1,000 hours for non-emergency use; enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through $6,037
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect 26 kW 24 26 206 94 ft3/h 540 7 years parts, labor and travel (generator, domestic and Canada); 7 years or 1,000 hours for non-emergency use; enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through not published
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect+ 18 kW 18 18 176 77 ft3/h 490 7 years parts, labor and travel for emergency stationary use (generator, USA and Canada); 7 years or 1,000 hours for non-emergency stationary use; enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through $6,135
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect+ 22 kW 22 22 194 87 ft3/h 490 7 years parts, labor and travel for emergency stationary use (generator, USA and Canada); 7 years or 1,000 hours for non-emergency stationary use; enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through $6,532
Briggs & Stratton PowerProtect+ 26 kW 24 26 206 94 ft3/h 545 7 years parts, labor and travel for emergency stationary use (generator, USA and Canada); 7 years or 1,000 hours for non-emergency stationary use; enclosure 1 year surface rust, 3 years rust through $7,336
Champion aXis 14 kW 12.5 14 116.5 1.6 438.7 10 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and mileage in years 1 and 2, parts only in years 3 through 10 not published
Champion aXis 22 kW 19.8 22 173.4 2 590.4 10 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and mileage in years 1 and 2, parts only in years 3 through 10 not published
Generac Guardian 10 kW 9 10 101 36 ft3/h 338 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Generac Guardian 14 kW 14 14 195 65 ft3/h 385 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Generac Guardian 18 kW 17 18 169 62 ft3/h 420 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Generac Guardian 22 kW 19.5 22 228 92 ft3/h 466 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Generac Guardian 24 kW 21 24 203 92 ft3/h 455 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Generac Guardian 26 kW 22.5 26 188 75 ft3/h 518 5 years or 2,000 hours, whichever occurs first: parts, labor and limited travel in years 1 and 2, parts only in year 3, engine short block and alternator only in years 4 and 5 not published
Kohler 10RESV 9 10 120 52 ft3/h 428 5 years or 2,000 hours, premium limited standby warranty covering parts, labor and travel for the full period $3,946
Kohler 12RESV 11 12 128 57 ft3/h 433 5 years or 2,000 hours, premium limited standby warranty covering parts, labor and travel for the full period $4,384
Kohler 14RCA 12 14 124 60 ft3/h 452.5 5 years or 2,000 hours, premium limited standby warranty covering parts, labor and travel for the full period $5,098
Kohler 20RCA 18 20 161 82 ft3/h 567.5 5 years or 2,000 hours, premium limited standby warranty covering parts, labor and travel for the full period $6,016
Kohler 26RCA 24 26 180 85 ft3/h 670 5 years or 2,000 hours, premium limited standby warranty covering parts, labor and travel for the full period $7,546

Fuel and long outages

The weak spot of a portable is fuel. Gasoline goes stale in storage, and in a wide outage gas stations may close or have lines. Propane stores better but cylinders run out. The gas vs propane guide covers both.

A standby generator on natural gas runs as long as the gas utility keeps supplying it. On propane it runs as long as the tank lasts, which depends on the tank size and the load. Each standby model page lists fuel use at half and full load from the maker's spec sheet, so you or your propane supplier can work out days of runtime.

Convenience and who's home

A portable needs someone able to set it up in the dark, in rain or snow, and refuel it every several hours. That's fine for many households. It's a real problem if you travel, if the person who knows the setup is away, or if anyone in the house depends on power for medical equipment.

A standby unit needs nothing during an outage. It does need annual maintenance, which many owners have a dealer do.

Safety

The main risk with a portable is where it runs. Run it outside only, at least 20 ft from the house, with the exhaust directed away from the home and other buildings. Never run it inside a home, garage, basement, crawlspace or shed, or on a porch [7].

Standby units are installed outside to the maker's clearances by licensed trades, which removes the placement decision during an outage.

Both need proper isolation from the utility. Feeding a panel from a portable needs an interlock kit or transfer switch installed by a licensed electrician; standby uses an automatic transfer switch. The interlock vs transfer switch guide explains the options.

A middle path

Some people start with a portable generator and an interlock kit, then move to standby later. The inlet and interlock aren't wasted; they can stay as a backup for the standby unit. Others pair a standby unit for the house with a power station for quiet electronics.

Size either one from your load list:

Example: a refrigerator, LED lights, a phone charger and a TV
Appliance RunningW Starting for sizingW
Refrigerator 780 W 1,200 W (chart)
LED lights 9 W 9 W
Phone charger 20 W 20 W
TV 219 W 219 W
Running total
1,028 W
Starting peak
1,448 W
Recommended size
2,000 W

The running total divided by the continuous-load factor of 0.8 is 1,285 W. The starting peak is the running total plus the largest single surge. The larger of the two, rounded up to the next listed size, is the recommendation. Starting watts for Refrigerator come from the generator maker's chart, because the sampled spec sheets print no surge figure.

Size your own list in the calculator

FAQ

Is a standby generator worth it over a portable?

It depends on how often and how long you lose power, and who is home. For frequent or long outages, central air, medical equipment or households where nobody can set up a portable, standby is often worth it. For occasional short outages and essentials, a portable with an interlock covers it for far less.

Can a portable generator power a whole house?

A large portable with a 240 V outlet can power much of a house through an interlock kit or transfer switch, if you manage which breakers are on. It won't usually run central air, an electric water heater and an electric range together. Standby with load management handles that automatically.

How long can a standby generator run?

On natural gas, as long as the utility keeps gas flowing, with breaks for oil checks per the owner's manual on long runs. On propane, until the tank runs low, which depends on tank size and load. Each standby model page lists fuel use at half and full load from the spec sheet.

Do standby generators need maintenance?

Yes. They run a short self-test on a schedule and need oil, filter and spark plug service at the intervals in the owner's manual. Some owners buy a dealer maintenance plan. A portable needs similar engine care plus fuel management.

Page data checked on