Gas vs propane generator

Gasoline carries more energy per gallon, so a generator usually makes more watts and runs longer per gallon on gas. Propane wins on storage: it doesn't go stale in the tank, and you can keep cylinders for years. For outage backup, many people buy dual fuel to get both, then size from the propane rating.

Updated

The short comparison

Gasoline Propane
Energy per gallon 120,214 Btu 91,452 Btu
Output on a dual fuel model Higher rating Lower rating
Storage Degrades over time; needs stabilizer and rotation Doesn't degrade; container condition is the limit
Refueling during an outage Stations need power to pump Swap a cylinder; exchanges may run short in a long event
Carburetor gum after storage Common cause of no-start Not an issue with propane
Cold weather Starts fine with fresh fuel Small cylinders vaporize slower in deep cold

Energy figures are from the U.S. Energy Information Administration, as stored in this site's constants.

Why propane makes less power

Gasoline holds 120,214 Btu per gallon and propane holds 91,452 Btu per gallon. An engine built to run on both makes less power on propane, so dual fuel generators publish two ratings.

The gap varies by model, which is why the dual fuel generators page lists running watts on each fuel side by side, straight from each maker's spec sheet. When you size, use the propane figure if propane is the fuel you plan to rely on. A generator that covers your load on gasoline can come up short on propane.

The same is true for home standby units, which run on natural gas or propane. The Generac Guardian 22 kW is rated at 19,500 W on natural gas and 22,000 W on propane. The standby sizing guide covers that side.

Runtime per gallon

Propane carries less energy per gallon, so a generator burns more gallons of propane than gasoline for the same load. A standard grill cylinder is sold by weight, not gallons, which makes the comparison harder at a glance.

Model pages show every published runtime with the load and fuel it was measured on. Compare runtimes at the same load and on the same fuel. A figure with no load stated isn't comparable with anything.

Storage is where propane wins

Gasoline breaks down in storage. A propane supplier, Ferrellgas, puts the contrast plainly: gasoline and diesel degrade with time, and propane doesn't [16]. Old gasoline also leaves gum in a carburetor, the classic reason a generator that sat all year won't start when the power goes out.

If you choose gasoline:

  • add fuel stabilizer when you fill the can
  • rotate stored gas into your car and refill
  • run the generator every month or two, or drain the carburetor before storage, following the owner's manual

If you choose propane, the cylinder is the limit. Keep cylinders upright and outside, check the valve and the date stamp, and follow your supplier's guidance on requalification.

Refueling during a long outage

Gas stations need electricity to run their pumps. In a wide outage, some close and the open ones have lines. Propane exchange cages can empty too, but a full cylinder you already own is fuel in hand. Homes with a large propane tank for heating can have a dual fuel or propane generator plumbed by a licensed gas fitter.

Cold weather

Propane in a small cylinder has to vaporize to reach the engine, and in deep cold a small cylinder vaporizes slower, which can limit output. Larger tanks hold up better. Gasoline generators start fine in the cold with fresh fuel and the right oil. Check the cold-weather section of the owner's manual for either fuel.

Cost

Fuel prices move, so compare in cost per hour at your load, not cost per gallon. Exchange cylinders, refills and bulk delivery to a home tank are priced differently, so get local prices for the way you would actually buy it.

Dual fuel: the common answer

A dual fuel generator runs on either fuel. You can start on stored propane, keep gasoline as a backup, and not worry about a can of stale gas. The site lists 59 dual fuel models on the dual fuel page, and propane generators covers propane-capable units in general.

Size a dual fuel generator from its propane rating if propane is your main plan. Use the calculator to get your load.

Example: a refrigerator, LED lights, a phone charger and a TV
Appliance RunningW Starting for sizingW
Refrigerator 780 W 1,200 W (chart)
LED lights 9 W 9 W
Phone charger 20 W 20 W
TV 219 W 219 W
Running total
1,028 W
Starting peak
1,448 W
Recommended size
2,000 W

The running total divided by the continuous-load factor of 0.8 is 1,285 W. The starting peak is the running total plus the largest single surge. The larger of the two, rounded up to the next listed size, is the recommendation. Starting watts for Refrigerator come from the generator maker's chart, because the sampled spec sheets print no surge figure.

Size your own list in the calculator

Safety is the same on either fuel

Both fuels produce carbon monoxide. Run the generator outside only, at least 20 ft from the house with the exhaust pointed away from the home, and never inside a home, garage, basement, crawlspace or shed [7]. Store gasoline in approved cans away from living space, and keep propane cylinders outdoors.

FAQ

Is propane or gas better for a generator?

Gas gives more watts and longer runtime per gallon. Propane stores for years without going bad and avoids carburetor gum. For outage backup, propane or dual fuel is popular because the fuel is ready when the power fails. For maximum power from a given generator, gasoline wins.

How much power do you lose running a generator on propane?

It depends on the model. Dual fuel makers publish a separate running rating for propane, and it's lower than the gasoline rating. The dual fuel page shows both ratings for each model from the maker's spec sheet, so you can see the exact gap for the unit you're considering.

Does propane last longer than gasoline in storage?

Yes. Propane doesn't degrade in the tank, so the limit is the condition of the cylinder and valve. Gasoline breaks down over time, even with stabilizer extending its life. That's why many people keep propane for outage backup and use gasoline only for regular use.

Can I convert a gas generator to propane?

Conversion kits exist for some engines, but they change how the generator is certified and may affect the warranty and emissions compliance. A factory dual fuel model is simpler. If you convert, follow the kit maker's instructions and check the generator maker's warranty terms first.

Page data checked on